Some classic PC games are still well worth playing despite their age, while others are remembered more fondly than they actually play. Here are eight from our catalogue that hold up well today, grouped by what you fancy playing, with why they still hook you and, above all, what has aged worse in each one so you don't end up disappointed.

What makes a classic hold up

Before the list, three things that separate a classic you'll enjoy from one that's pure nostalgia:

  • Ideas that don't depend on the graphics. Good writing, a world with personality or an original mechanic never go out of date; visual effects do.
  • Controls that don't fight you. This is what ages worst: stiff cameras, odd menus or shortcuts nobody would design today.
  • Being able to buy and play it today without workarounds. Everything on this list is on Steam. Even so, check the language options and Steam Deck compatibility, which vary a lot from one game to the next.

Story shooters that haven't fallen behind

Half-Life 2 is the perfect example of a classic that has aged well. Gordon Freeman joins the resistance against an alien regime in an occupied city, and the game keeps changing pace: firefights, vehicles, horror sections and physics puzzles with the gravity gun, which can throw any object. Each chapter fits into an hour or two and the full story takes around 10-15 hours. According to Steam, it has full controller support and is Verified for Steam Deck. The caveat: if you want non-stop action, it has slower stretches of exploration and puzzles.

BioShock takes you to Rapture, a ruined art deco city under the sea. You combine guns with fire, ice or electricity plasmids, hack machines and decide whether to save or harvest the little girls escorted by the Big Daddies, a choice that changes the ending. What keeps it alive is the atmosphere and piecing together what happened from audio recordings. If you're after a challenge, be warned: by default, dying barely matters, because a Vita-Chamber brings you back (they can be switched off).

Classic RPGs to sink weeks into

Fallout: New Vegas is one of those games people still recommend for its writing. You're in the Mojave Desert after the nuclear war, with several factions fighting for control of New Vegas, and you can side with whoever you like, with choices that genuinely change the ending. The main story takes around 20-30 hours. What has aged: the technical side is dated and it has the odd bug. If you care more about factions and dialogue than graphics, you won't mind.

STAR WARS Knights of the Old Republic is a classic Star Wars RPG set 4,000 years before the Empire. You travel from planet to planet with two companions, fight in round-based combat you can pause, and almost every quest has a light side or dark side solution. You recruit nine companions, each with their own story. The warning in its ‘game details’ matters: the opening is slow, as you spend the first few hours on Taris without the Force or a lightsaber. Get through that start and you've got an adventure that lasts.

If you're left wanting more, we have a list of long RPGs to get lost in for weeks.

A point-and-click adventure to make you laugh

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition is the most comfortable way to play a LucasArts classic. Guybrush Threepwood wants to be a pirate: you talk to everyone, pick up anything that isn't nailed down and use it in absurd puzzles, and sword fights are won with insults. It's a remake with new voices and artwork that lets you switch to the original whenever you like, so you can compare. You can finish it in a few afternoons and you can barely die.

What has aged worst is the logic of some puzzles: if unconventional solutions drive you mad, keep a walkthrough handy and don't feel guilty about it.

Platformers and action you can finish in a few afternoons

Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time has acrobatics that still feel fluid. The Prince runs along walls, leaps between columns and dodges traps, and with the Dagger of Time he can rewind up to ten seconds to undo a bad jump. One review reckons it takes under ten hours to finish. What has aged is the combat: there are few moves and it gets repetitive quickly.

Psychonauts is the classic on this list that asks you to forgive the most, and it's still worth it. Raz, a boy with psychic powers, sneaks into a summer camp and ends up jumping inside other characters' minds: each mind is a different surreal level, full of humour. It works well in hour-long sessions. The caveat: the controls and camera have aged badly in some sections.

A classic for all ages

Plants vs. Zombies GOTY Edition is light strategy anyone can pick up: you plant sunflowers to generate sun and place peashooters, wall-nuts and cherry bombs to hold back waves of increasingly strange zombies. Each level lasts a few minutes, so it's perfect for short sessions or for playing with kids. If you've already mastered tower defence games, you'll find the campaign gentle. According to Steam, it isn't supported on Steam Deck.

How to choose your classic

  • You want one that plays like it came out today: Half-Life 2.
  • You fancy atmosphere and a story you uncover as you go: BioShock.
  • You're after an RPG with choices for many hours: Fallout: New Vegas or Knights of the Old Republic.
  • You want to laugh and think at your own pace: The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition.
  • You've got a couple of afternoons and fancy some acrobatics: Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time.
  • You value imagination over modern controls: Psychonauts.
  • You have short sessions or you'll be playing with the family: Plants vs. Zombies.
  • You play on Steam Deck: Half-Life 2 is Verified by Steam; the rest, apart from Plants vs. Zombies, are listed as Playable.

Fancy a classic today?

You may already have one of these in your library without having started it. Tell us how much time and energy you have and we'll suggest one; if you connect your Steam account, we'll pick from the games you already own.

Now

So what are you playing now?

Tell us how much time you have and what you fancy, and we'll suggest a game in under a minute.

Find my game